Selecting a Venue – Carfagna's Catering

Selecting a Venue

Deciding where to have your event or party is not always easy: so many choices that all seem to have different requirements. The Carfagna’s Catering team help. Our customers have hosted events all across Central Ohio, and we know how to work with each venue. Whether you’re looking for elegance, a more rustic, casual setting, or maybe something in between, we can suggest some great options. You can either book the space yourself, or let us handle everything for you.

Listed below are some of the event spaces we can recommend to our customers. We’re listing them by location to make it easy for you to keep your event in the area you prefer.  Venues marked with an * require that you supply your own liquor—but don’t worry, Carfagana’s Catering can take care of that for you, too! We want your event to be everything you want it to be. Start planning today.

Event Spaces – North

Rustic (north)Elegant (north)A Mix of Both (north)
St. Elizabeth Church Hall*
Up to 250 guests
614.891.0150
Camp Mary Orton*
Up to 200 guests
614.885.1023
Haimeral Center*
Up to 250 guests
614.267.0121
Immaculate Conception
Church Hall*
Up to 400 guests
614.267.9241
Everial Barn*
Up to 100 guests
614.901.6570
Westerville Community Center
Up to 150 guests
No alcohol permitted
Nationwide & Ohio Farm Bureau Center*
Up to 250 guests
614.247.6904
Park of Roses Shelter House*
Up to 125 guests
614.645.3337
Little Bear Golf Club
Up to 200 guests
Their alcohol
740.548.8532
St. John Neumann Sunbury*
Up to 200 guests
740.965.1358
York Temple Golf Club
Up to 200 guests
Their alcohol
614.885.5968
Brookshire
Up to 250 guests
Their alcohol
740.548.8188

Event Spaces – Northeast

Rustic (northeast)Elegant (northeast)A Mix of Both (northeast)
Jorgensen Farms*
Up to 250 guests
614.855.2697
Church of the Resurrection Hall*
Up to 350 guests
614.855.1400
Olde Sanctuary*
Up to 175 guests
614.475.9265
Jeffrey Mansion Bexley*
Up to 100 guests
614.559.4301  
Noah’s Event Center
Up to 250 guests
Their alcohol
614.943.9886
Bryn Du Mansion, Granville*
Up to 150 guests
740.587.7053
Bryn Du Fieldhouse, Granville*
Up to 400 guests
740.587.7053
Skylight Newark
Up to 250 guests
Their alcohol
740.973-9442

Event Spaces – Northwest

Rustic (northwest)Elegant (northwest)A Mix of Both (northwest)
Amelita Mirolo Barn*
Up yo 175 guests
614.583.5330
St. Agatha Church Hall*
Up to 350 guests
614.488.6149
St. Andrew Activity Center*
Up to 100 guests
614.459.1402
Griggs Boathouse*
Up to 100 guests
614.645.3337

Event Spaces – Downtown Columbus

Rustic (downtown)Elegant (downtown)A Mix of Both (downtown)
Ohio Historical Society*
Up to 300 guests
614.298.2915
Cultural Arts Center*
Up to 150 guests
614.636.3278
The Vault
Up to 250 guests
Their alcohol
614.225.1000
Kelton House*
Up to 100 guests
614.464.2022
Northbank Pavillon*
Up to 200 guests
614.645.8760

Event Spaces – South

Rustic (south)Elegant (south)A Mix of Both (south)
White Star Farms*
Up to 250 guests
614.578.4324
Blue Moon Hall Grove City*
Up to 150 guests
614.871.7100